Considering Nationwide for travel insurance and wondering if their household name recognition translates into reliable coverage and smooth claims processing?
As a senior travel planner who has worked with clients for over two decades, I understand the appeal of choosing a familiar insurance company for travel protection.
However, name recognition doesn’t always guarantee the best travel insurance experience, and Nationwide’s approach has some distinct characteristics every traveler should understand before purchasing.
This comprehensive analysis examines Nationwide’s travel insurance operation, customer service patterns, and whether they deserve consideration for your travel protection needs.
In this article...
Claims Processing and Customer Experience
Based on extensive analysis of customer feedback, Nationwide shows notably inconsistent performance patterns that reflect their approach as a general insurance company rather than a travel insurance specialist.
Positive Experience Pattern: Some customers report excellent service: “Nationwide customer service was outstanding to work with, the claims process was easy, and the claim was processed and paid expeditiously,” noted one Squaremouth reviewer.
Challenging Experience Pattern: However, significant issues emerge with complex claims: “We cancelled our trip for medical reasons on 1/3/2025 and filed a claim. It took 3 months, innumerable phone calls and a complaint to the Colorado Division of Insurance to finally get paid,” reported a BBB complainant.
Another customer noted: “Travel Insurance is not worth it with this company. There are so many stipulations on paying a claim that unless the airlines goes bankrupt or there is a weather event, you don’t get your claim paid.”
The pattern suggests Nationwide applies traditional property/casualty insurance claim practices to travel insurance, which can create friction for travel-specific situations.
💡Personal Note: I’ve noticed that large multi-line insurers like Nationwide often struggle with travel insurance because their claims adjusters are trained on auto and property claims, not the nuances of travel disruptions. A delayed flight might seem straightforward, but proving causation and covered expenses requires different expertise than a car accident claim.
Financial Strength and Company Background
Founded in 1926 as Farm Bureau Mutual Automobile Insurance Company, Nationwide brings nearly a century of insurance experience to their travel insurance operation.
Nationwide and its subsidiaries maintain “Superior” (A+) financial ratings from AM Best, providing solid security for claims payment.
However, Nationwide operates as a general insurance company offering travel insurance as one of many product lines, rather than specializing in travel protection.
Their travel insurance plans are underwritten by Nationwide Mutual Insurance Company, administered through Co-ordinated Benefit Plans, LLC.
This structure means you’re dealing with a large, financially stable insurer but one where travel insurance represents a small portion of their overall business focus.
The company sells both directly to consumers and through various distribution channels including online travel agencies.
Recommended Plans
Up to $2,000,000 of Overall Maximum Coverage, Emergency Medical Evacuation, Medical coverage for eligible expenses related to COVID-19, Trip Interruption & Travel Delay.
Coverage for in-patient and out-patient medical accidents up to $1 Million, Coverage of acute episodes of pre-existing conditions, Coverage from 5 days to 364 days (about 12 months).
Up to $8,000,000 limits, Emergency Medical Evacuation, Coinsurance for treatment received in the U.S. (100% within PPO Network), Acute Onset of Pre-Existing Conditions covered.
Product Portfolio and Market Position
Nationwide offers a focused but limited travel insurance portfolio compared to specialized travel insurers.
Single-Trip Plans:
- Essential (basic coverage with modest limits)
- Prime (enhanced coverage with higher limits)
Cruise Insurance:
- Universal, Choice, and Luxury cruise-specific plans
- Recognized by multiple publications as “best for cruise insurance”
Multi-Trip Plans:
- Annual coverage starting at $59 for frequent travelers
- Customizable trip cancellation coverage
Nationwide’s strength lies in cruise insurance, where they offer three dedicated plans with cruise-specific benefits like itinerary changes, mechanical breakdowns, and shipboard service disruptions.
Their general travel insurance plans provide solid basic coverage but lack the specialized features and high limits offered by dedicated travel insurers.
✅ Pro Tip: Nationwide works best for cruise travelers who want insurance designed specifically for cruise scenarios. For general travel insurance, especially to exotic destinations or for expensive trips, specialized travel insurers typically offer better coverage and more experienced claims handling.
Pricing Philosophy and Value Proposition
Nationwide positions itself in the mid-range pricing category for most travelers, though some customers report higher-than-expected premiums.
Their Essential plan targets budget-conscious travelers, while the Prime plan offers more comprehensive protection at higher price points.
Multi-trip plans starting at $59 annually represent good value for frequent travelers who don’t need extensive coverage.
The company’s pricing reflects their general insurance approach – straightforward coverage at predictable prices without the bells and whistles of specialized travel insurers.
Optional upgrades like Cancel For Any Reason (CFAR) are available but limited to the Prime plan and not available in all states.
Strengths and Weaknesses Analysis
| Strengths | Weaknesses |
|---|---|
| Nearly 100 years of insurance experience | Mixed claims processing experiences |
| A+ financial rating from AM Best | Limited travel insurance specialization |
| Strong cruise insurance offerings | Strict policy interpretation reported |
| Multi-trip plans available | Customer service inconsistencies |
| Household name recognition | Limited high-end coverage options |
Buying Travel Insurance Online
Can Save Up to 30%!
Target Customer Analysis
Nationwide works best for cruise travelers who can benefit from their specialized cruise insurance plans.
The provider suits travelers who prefer dealing with a large, established insurance company and don’t need exotic destination coverage or extremely high limits.
Their multi-trip plans appeal to frequent domestic travelers who want basic annual coverage without complexity.
Consider alternatives if you’re taking expensive international trips, need specialized adventure coverage, or prioritize travel insurance expertise over general insurance company stability.
Budget travelers might find better value with specialized travel insurers, while luxury travelers typically need higher limits than Nationwide’s standard offerings provide.
Customer Service Quality and Accessibility
Nationwide provides 24/7 claims reporting and maintains extensive customer service infrastructure as a major insurer.
However, customer feedback reveals inconsistencies in travel insurance-specific knowledge among representatives.
Positive experiences highlight helpful, responsive service for straightforward claims.
Negative experiences focus on lengthy claim review processes and representatives who apply general insurance practices to travel-specific situations.
The company’s size provides stability but can create bureaucratic delays for complex travel insurance claims requiring specialized interpretation.
❌ Avoid: Nationwide if you prioritize travel insurance expertise and specialized customer service. Their general insurance approach can create frustration for complex travel claims that require industry-specific knowledge and flexible interpretation.
Industry Recognition and Market Reputation
Multiple publications recognize Nationwide as “best for cruise insurance,” highlighting their specialized cruise coverage as a market strength.
CNBC Select and Money magazine include Nationwide in their travel insurance recommendations, primarily for cruise travelers.
However, customer review platforms show mixed ratings, with a low 0.2% negative review rate on Squaremouth but concerning patterns in BBB complaints.
SuperMoney gives Nationwide travel insurance a “STRONGLY NOT RECOMMENDED” rating based on customer reviews, suggesting significant customer satisfaction issues.
ℹ️ Fun Fact: Nationwide’s cruise insurance includes coverage for “shipboard service disruption” – if the ship’s dining, entertainment, or other services are suspended, you can receive reimbursement. This specialized coverage reflects their deep understanding of cruise-specific risks that general travel insurers often overlook.
Alternatives to Consider
For Cruise Travel: While Nationwide excels in this area, Berkshire Hathaway Travel Protection also offers excellent cruise coverage with potentially faster claims processing.
For General Travel: Specialized providers like Travel Insured International or IMG offer more comprehensive coverage and travel-specific expertise.
For Frequent Travelers: Companies like Allianz offer more robust annual plans with higher limits and better international coverage.
Bottom Line Assessment
Nationwide represents a solid choice for cruise travelers seeking specialized coverage from a financially stable, established insurer.
Their nearly century of insurance experience and A+ financial rating provide confidence in their ability to pay claims.
However, their general insurance approach creates challenges for travelers seeking specialized travel insurance expertise or dealing with complex international travel scenarios.
If you’re taking a cruise and want insurance designed specifically for cruise risks, Nationwide deserves serious consideration.
For other travel scenarios, especially expensive international trips or adventure travel, specialized travel insurers typically offer better coverage, expertise, and customer experiences.
You can compare their plans with specialized travel insurance providers here to determine the best fit for your specific travel protection needs.
Always review the full policy wording carefully before purchasing. Safe travels!
Buying Travel Insurance Online
Can Save Up to 30%!
